CT News Junkie

A Connecticut news site that understands the usual media offerings just…aren’t…enough.

OP-ED | Starry-eyed State GOP Needs To Change Course

by | Sep 4, 2015 4:30am () Comments | Commenting has expired | Share
Posted to: Analysis, US Foreign Policy, Congress, Election 2016, Election Policy, Opinion

Will state Republicans never learn? I understand the GOP is in something of a bind. The state is dominated from top to bottom by Democrats. But if it is ever to become competitive again, the second-class party has got to look beyond celebrities, multi-millionaires, and retreads when searching for candidates for high-profile state offices.

The latest flirtations involve a pair of television personalities who happen to live in Fairfield County. CNBC host Larry Kudlow, a well known Republican, said last week on his radio show that he would run against Richard Blumenthal next year if the senator voted for President Obama’s proposed deal to limit Iran’s nuclear program.

Gage Skidmore - wikimedia.org Kudlow briefly considered a run in 2010 against Blumenthal and in New York against incumbent Sen. Chuck Schumer, but ultimately declined. There are advantages, after all, of living in two states.

Kudlow, who lives part-time in Redding, joins MSNBC host and former congressman Joe Scarborough, a New Canaan resident who has not yet announced but is looking and sounding like he wants to run for governor in 2018, if not sooner.

Wikipedia In the last couple of years, Scarborough has taken a number of steps to ingratiate himself with state political observers. He’s had Gov. Dannel P. Malloy on Morning Joe at least half a dozen times. He’s made the ongoing Connecticut budget-and-business-climate drama an occasional topic for discussion on the nationally televised cable show with co-host Mika Brzezinski, a familiar face to Nutmeggers from her days as a reporter for WFSB-TV.

In June, Scarborough appeared on Face The State to talk state government and his love of Connecticut with Dennis House. Perhaps most significantly, Scarborough hosted a dinner with Connecticut VIPs this summer at his home to discuss the state’s future.

Then on Aug. 20 Scarborough was the keynote speaker and host of the kick-off event at Fairfield University of an anti-tax campaign sponsored by the Yankee Institute, a conservative think tank based in Hartford.

Is Scarborough running? He’s clearly keeping his options open. Scarborough says he loves the state and has chosen to make it home. At any rate, he’ll need to bone up on the issues, if his misleading pronouncements in June on the controversial unitary reporting tax on corporations are any indication.

No Connecticut Republican has emerged victorious in a statewide race since M. Jodi Rell won a full term as governor in 2006 — the same year Chris Shays was the last GOPer to win a congressional race here. At that time, Republicans made up 25 percent of the state’s registered voters. Since then that percentage has slipped to 20. Meanwhile, wrestling magnate Linda McMahon and private-equity guy Tom Foley — rich people from Greenwich who largely self-funded their campaigns — both took a pair of unsuccessful cracks at the U.S. Senate and the governor’s mansion respectively.

During Foley’s second try, Republicans at the convention and in the primary chose Foley’s deep pockets over two credible homegrown candidates: Danbury Mayor Mark Boughton and Senate Minority Leader John McKinney. Boughton is a proven executive, while McKinney remains well respected on both sides of the aisle. But the starry-eyed party bosses and primary activists again went for the deep pockets — and where did it get them? Four humiliating losses in four years. Meanwhile next door in Massachusetts, Republicans comprise only 11 percent of the electorate, but they still managed to get one of their own elected governor last year.

Kudlow and Scarborough are both blustering cable news commentators who are thin on governmental experience and have never run large organizations. Scarborough might be more credible as a candidate, having served in public office before, but his three-and-a-half terms in Congress were largely undistinguished.

I realize the Republicans have a thin bench, at least in contrast to the majority party, but as the last few years have demonstrated, there are credible GOP candidates out there. One GOP disappointment has to be that rising star Sean Williams left the House in 2013 to become — you guessed it — a lobbyist. Maybe Williams could be lured back?

Ironically, the GOP in Connecticut might have been consigned to oblivion if not for the state’s minority representation law, which guarantees that no party can have more than two-thirds control over an elected municipal board or commission. Unfortunately for the Republicans, that same boneheaded law exempts legislative bodies large enough for its members to represent individual districts or wards, freeing up the General Assembly and the largest cities to be lorded over by Democrats, while preventing the Republicans from dominating the smaller towns where they’re strongest.

One thing is certain, however. If Connecticut Republicans don’t change their strategy, they’ll be living proof of Einstein’s definition of insanity.

Contributing op-ed columnist Terry Cowgill lives in Lakeville, blogs at ctdevilsadvocate.com and is news editor of The Berkshire Record in Great Barrington, Mass. Follow him on Twitter @terrycowgill.

DISCLAIMER: The views, opinions, positions, or strategies expressed by the author are theirs alone, and do not necessarily reflect the views, opinions, or positions of CTNewsJunkie.com.

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Share this story with others.

Share | |


(8) Archived Comments

posted by: BFlood | September 4, 2015  8:33am

Great piece Terry. The CTGOP is doing a disservice to the state by looking for glamorous quick-fixes instead of building a worthy political party. You’re spot-on.
Except for one thing—Einstein never said that.

posted by: SocialButterfly | September 4, 2015  8:51am

@Terry Cowgill: Give J.R. Romano new GOP party chairman a chance to do something before you ask: “
Starry-eyed GOP Needs to Change Course.”  J.R.can’t make it happen overnight.

posted by: JamesBronsdon | September 4, 2015  9:24am

Sheesh, you can’t really be equating Kudlow and Scarborough with McMahon (know nothing) and Foley (no personality).  Kudlow is an economist, a Reagan administration official and involved in a number of governmental commissions. (10 seconds on Wikipedia).  Scarborough has personality galore and is a decent conservative voice on a long-running political show on a left wing network.  No comparison.

posted by: Terry Cowgill | September 4, 2015  10:38am

Terry Cowgill

@SocialButterfly: Maybe Mr. Romano needs a little encouragement ...

@JamesBronsdon: Obviously Kudlow and Scarborough are not the same people as McMahon and Foley.

My point is that the GOP in CT needs to build a party with candidates for statewide office from the ground up and not by recruiting wealth celebs who have developed a sudden craving for acquiring political power. The latter formula simply hasn’t worked.

I guess your point is that Kudlow and/or Scarborough are a different breed of wealthy outsider and this time they could actually win. Scarborough is a possibility but Kudlow is simply too far to the right to win a statewide race in this blue state.

@BFlood: Thank you. There are various wonderful quotes mistakenly attributed to famous people that turned out to be apocryphal. Mussolini, for example, never actually made the trains run on time but that’s another matter ...

posted by: ACR | September 4, 2015  10:52am


“Meanwhile next door in Massachusetts, Republicans comprise only 11 percent of the electorate, but they still managed to get one of their own elected governor last year.

Let’s not forget who ran Bakers campaign - Connecticut’s own Jim Conroy.

posted by: JamesBronsdon | September 4, 2015  1:02pm

Terry, I agree with your point, but it will not do to compare animate and inanimate things to make the point.  Both Kudlow and Scarborough are thoroughly engaged in the issues and able to speak to them adroitly.  Not so the prior pretendees.  I would not dismiss them so quickly.  Let’s see how Trump does before we dismiss the anti-celebrity bias.  But build the bench by all means, and Boughton would have been an excellent candidate.

posted by: LongJohn47 | September 4, 2015  5:12pm

I think you’re right about Kudlow and wrong about Scarborough.  Blumenthal has won state-wide many, many times, and is on track to repeat in 2016 against virtually anyone.

The Governor’s race in 2018 is another matter entirely.  The Dems have several well-qualified potential candidates who would do a good job of running the state, but no one with star power like Morning Joe. 

This is not the Wrestling Lady or the former Irish Ambassador/Bush Pioneer.  This is a man who has a national platform, an incredibly well-honed instinct for political media, and tons of money to boot.

Joe could win.  Could he govern?  Who knows.  It’s a long way from being a Congressman under Gingrich or running a morning talk show.  But Democrats should clearly be concerned.

posted by: SocialButterfly | September 5, 2015  1:46pm

@Terry Cowgill: J.R. Romano is self-driven and needs little encouragement but I always encourage him anyway. He aims to succeed.

Social Networks We Use

Connecticut Network


Our Partners

Sponsored Messages